Thoughts on S60

reflections on the most popular mobile operating system worldwide

Archive for the ‘iPhone’ Category

Samsung i8910HD Review: THE device of 2009?

with 23 comments

The road to getting myself settled with a Samsung i8910HD has certainly been a long one. After going through 2 defective 8gb i8910HD’s and getting a 16gb that works properly, about a dozen headaches trying to get the firmware software installed and running properly on my PC, and going through almost all of the different available firmwares for the phone, I’ve finally gotten myself comfortable enough to write a proper review. Hopefully I’ll be able to highlight some features of the i8910HD that haven’t been featured in any of the other reviews that have already been published and shed some light on how the i8910HD performs for those who can’t handle one themselves so easily.

I purchased two defective 8gb i8910HD’s from CellsWholesale (pending a full refund) and I purchased the 16gb i8910HD used in this review from Mobile City Online for $725 total ($699+25 overnight shipping, now backordered).

Thanks to all who attended the live Q+A on Qik! If you missed it (and have a couple hours to kill), you can watch the full video here.

Read the rest of this entry »

Advertisements

N97 Tour: Day 11, Chicago Mobile Camp

with one comment

Saturday was our third and final Mobile Camp at the Illinois Institute of Technology and it was a very mixed bag. The turnout was very low with only two attendees, which was the least of the three. Despite this setback, a lot more personal discussion came out of having such a small group and it allowed everyone to expresss their opinions without anything getting lost.

The most interesting discussion to me that came up at all of the Mobile Camps was why the US market is so different from the rest of the markets where Nokia’s devices are sold. In short, the US market saw the rise of desktops before smartphones, whereas the Asian market saw just the opposite, and Europe saw the rise of both at almost the same time. With that said, it’s no surprise that the iPhone has become so successful in a market that’s trying to get a desktop to fit in their pocket efficiently and with the immense amount of control the carriers have. It emphasizes yet again that Nokia needs to market themselves completely different in the US than they do in other countries and I think efforts like this tour are certainly a step in the right direction.

We also put together a video of Matthew demonstrating the video editing software built into the N95 from years ago that hasn’t been seen on more recent offerings. After seeing the demo and becoming much more focused on mobile blogging on this trip, I’d very much like to see this feature brought back on handsets in the future.

Big thanks to Jeremiah (Pseudofinn) and Craig (SockMonkey) for making it out to the Mobile Camp! It was great to meet you guys and share so many thoughts about the mobile industry.

I personally don’t have any images from the event, but here’s a picture of a movie poster mixup seen near one of the trains we took back to the hotel.

“Right in the Mouth”
07182009045.jpg

Posted by Wordmobi

Quantity VS Quality: Looking at mobile device storage

leave a comment »

Aside from the megapixel race in mobile cameras, it seems we’ve seen a constant increase in demand for higher storage capacities as well. Although not the first mobile device to implement it, it seemed to start with the fixed 4 and 8gb iPhones in 2007, combatted by the N95 8gb, with the iPhone 3G in 8gb and 16gb variants fighting it out with the N96 the following year with 16gb+microSD slot (despite the N96 failing in several areas). It seems that this year is going to be no different with rumors flying that the next-gen iPhone is going to come in 16 and 32gb flavors to compete against the 32gb+microSD slotted N97. While I agree that more is almost certainly always going to be better in this regard, I believe there are conditions to be met to ensure that people are getting the most out of such an immense amount of storage.

Keep reading to understand what I’m talking about.

Read the rest of this entry »

Written by Jonathan

May 22, 2009 at 10:16 pm

The Trouble With Resistive

with one comment

I came across this picture the other day and was amazed at how well it visually captured everything I hate about resistive touch screens (the phone is the HTC Touch Diamond 2).

Notice the “waves” of the top layer of plastic that’s going to make contact with the user’s stylus and fingers. Having used several touch screens with this type of screen recently, the one thing I’ve noticed is that this top thin layer is anything but durable. Those “waves” will shift as you use the screen over time and even with normal usage or a screen protector applied, tiny skids and lines will start to appear over the surface. And you can absolutely forget about putting this phone in your pocket with keys. I’m not one to do such a thing (usually my phone has its own dedicated pocket), but I know there are people who do.

Comparing that experience to the durability of a capacitive screen with tempered glass is part of the reason I’m so geared up on using the i8910. I never found too much difficulty in normal usage or in clarity as I’ve heard other people complain about on phones like the 5800XM. My biggest gripe was how the screen felt like it was simply going to fall apart if I kept the phone any longer and seeing how quickly it developed a noticeable amount of wear after very little abuse. What I don’t understand is why this type of screen is still being used when thicker plastic layers have been used over resistive screens on other devices and have held up much better.

Check out these videos to see how much tempered glass makes a difference.

Written by Jonathan

May 15, 2009 at 3:16 pm

If you really want to gauge the US cell phone market…

leave a comment »

Take a look at the Cell Phones & Plans sections on Yahoo! Answers.


When you take a look at the wide variety of questions that a ton of different people ask about their mobiles and their plans every few seconds, it really kida puts things into perspective. That’s not to make fun of anyone in the US. I’m just trying to show that there are a lot more people in the US who have absolutely NO idea what’s out there or even how to use the free phone they just picked up from AT&T. Hell, a lot of them don’t even know how to find the information they’re looking for (other than to ask it on Yahoo! Answers). It makes me wonder how many people out there without computers are struggling as much or harder.

How are companies going to reach these people? And not just the big name hardware manufacturers, what about all of the software developers both big and small who have a killer application for their phone that’s either free or well worth the money? It makes me feel like Apple has made some very huge accomplishments in reaching out to those people, and they haven’t even begun to scratch the surface.

I don’t care what you think of the iPhone; these companies need to take a page out of Apple’s books.

Written by Jonathan

May 8, 2009 at 6:18 pm

5800 XpressMusic Mini Review Part 1: Calling

with 8 comments

Given how much my opinion of the 5800XM has fluctuated so much since I first received it, I think the only effective way I’ll be able to review it is in parts, similar to how the Guru is reviewing it. I would, however, like to review some of the lesser noticed features that people may be interested in rather than the main features that have been reviewed to death as it is already.

Click ahead to read how well I feel the 5800XM performs as a phone first.

Read the rest of this entry »

Written by Jonathan

January 9, 2009 at 7:37 am

Why buy an unlocked device in 2009?

with 9 comments

I’ve been chewing this question over in my head for a couple days now and a couple of recent articles really made things much more clear to me. I apologize in advance for the long read, but I think it will be worth your time if you care to give it.

How it was.

There was a time not too many years ago when owning an unlocked S60 device really meant something. They were usually much more expensive, freed users of any of the carrier restrictions placed on such devices due to branded firmware, and had a larger feature set than what was offered by carriers as well. I remember when I bought my 6630 with a 1.3mp camera when everyone else around me was first getting introduced to cameraphones altogether. When 1.3 became the standard, I was upgrading the 2mp camera on my N70 to the 3.2mp camera on the N80 and taking advantage of wifi on a phone, a thought that was unheard of by any carrier at the time. When the world finally got around to using 2mp as the standard and started rolling out provider-based GPS solutions, I was dropping a silly amount of money on my first N95 with a real GPS chipset and a whopping 5mp sensor, along with all of the other features I had grown used to over the years.

Despite the cost for these devices, there was an obvious advantage to them that was worth a conversation with someone who was looking for something that was more than what AT&T or Verizon could offer them. Since I started using S60, I’ve been so enthusiastic about it that I influenced more than a dozen friends, family members, and strangers to buy an unlocked Nokia rather than settle for the mediocre device offerings from carriers that came locked and ready to charge you for every bit of media you consume.

I spent a lot of money over the years to stay at the bleeding edge of this technology, but it was worth it.

Fast forward to today. Where are we?

-The iPhone undoubtedly has completely changed the market and how people perceive mobile devices. It appeals to people who struggled with Windows Mobile for its incredible ease of use, fashionistas who want a gorgeous piece of equipment in their pocket, mid-to-heavy power users who want an impressive device in their pocket, and it has become the new benchmark for a tier of device above your everyday cell phone without the complications of your typical smartphone offerings (usually Windows Mobile, Blackberry, and a bit of Palm still floating around).

-The HTC Touch Pro, a worthy iPhone competitor, will be offered by Sprint, AT&T, and Verizon for the 2008 holiday season.

-Verizon is launching the Blackberry Storm, yet another iPhone competitor, within the next couple weeks (allegedly by Black Friday).

-AT&T has several more devices planned for the holiday launch, including the Blackberry Bold, Samsung Eternity, Incite, Epix, and a few other devices geared towards enhanced messaging.

-In addition to the Touch Pro and the Blackberry Storm, Verizon is also launching the Samsung Omnia with 5mp camera (with many, many features), GPS, and everything else you’d want from a high end Windows Mobile device. It is also due out for this holiday season.

-T-Mobile just launched their first real iPhone contender in both hardware and software, the HTC G1 running Andoid.

Bare in mind, all of these carrier device offerings are new. They are an addition to all of the other devices that have already been rapidly catching up to what’s supposed to be the next generation of high end devices. Verizon had been all over the touch screen bandwagon for a while now with the likes of the HTC Touch, LG Voyager, Dare, Samsung Glyde, and the newly released Motorola Krave.

I’ve gotten to the point where switching to a different device and platform wouldn’t be much of a sacrifice at all if it were easy enough to learn, so what’s to stop anyone else from feeling the exact same? I’ve been with S60 for so long that it feels like second nature, but in a world with iPhones and iPhone-wannabes that are damn near immediately intuitive as soon as you pick it up and are starting to have the exact same feature sets as the once-coveted unlocked, imported smartphone, what does Nokia and/or S60 have that people are really going to want? And what’s going to make it worth the extra money for buying it without a contract?

Some would argue that it’s the operating system, the third party software, and the ease of use makes still makes it worthwhile. I would agree, but your average consumer wouldn’t. Part of the brilliance of S60 was a community of users with active development of the platform adding functionality on an almost daily basis. While that’s still very strong, there’s a much stronger presence available elsewhere now. Going back to the iPhone, Apple (and the community responsible for jailbreaking) took that same idea and unified all of the apps into a single source for convenient installation right on the device iteself, much like you’d see from a Linux distro. Speaking of which, Android has now done the exact same thing, and Blackberry is about to join the club as well. Nokia’s version is a patheric application called “Download!”, available on devices years before the iPhone, but it was hardly used then either. Download! brought a very small fraction of the most popular S60 applications for users to install right on their device with a clunky interface that doesn’t even compare to what’s available now.

The point? In both hardware and software, there are very few unlocked devices (current and available soon) that offer more than what’s already available from a carrier.

Why would somebody buy an N85 for $400+ dollars when a Samsung Omnia can be had for $100 less with a contract? It’s not worth it anymore.

I’m very content with my decision to buy the 5800 XpressMusic when the US version is available. I’m at a point in my life where having the absolute latest and greatest phone with all of the high end features is much less important to me than having a device I enjoy using that still matches what I need and what I need it to do on a daily basis. The difference now is that I also have no choice. Nokia doesn’t have a flagship that blows everything else out of the water like they used to year after year.

Nokia has sat at the top of their hill for a very, very long time, gradually milking out new phones with a minor upgrade here, a US version there, with the capability to be the dominant presence in all of its markets. With all of the recent changes, it’s not difficult to see how easily other manufacturers have been able to slowly eat away at their numbers.

————-

What does the future hold?

Nokia has three options if they ever intend to get back into the US market.

1) Get agreements with carriers.

2) Sell unlocked phones at competitive prices.

3) Start making phones worth the extra money and market the hell out of them.

Nokia is never going to have to worry about their doors closing. The lion’s share of their market is still heavily dominated by their lower-end handsets and most of these thoughts are intended for the US audience only. If Nokia intends to stay as successful as they have been for the past several years, then it’s time they start worrying. They have several new services that, if done properly, could retake control of the entire market; they just need to do it right.

I used to think about a day when things would change in the US. I thought that everyone would eventually catch on to the idea of unlocked phones, start to phase out the carrier as their source for new devices, and we’d gradually see an uprising of interest in mobile technology beyond just calling and sending SMS. Well, now we have, except the company that has done it was the newcomer to the market, and they did it with an even stronger relationship to mobile providers than ever before. Everyone asks “Who are you with?” instead of “Who makes that phone?” more than ever and we’re even further away from that changing anytime soon.

———-

As a fan of technology in general, I’m very excited to see how much everything is about to change even after they already have so much. Though I am still very happy with Nokia’s offerings, I wouldn’t have any reservations about purchasing a device that offered more for less, and I’m sure the majority of everyone else in the US feels the same way. 2009 holds a lot of new devices from a lot of manufacturers. The last thing Nokia needs to be doing is releasing rehashes of their previous years devices with new reflective black casings.

After all, that banner up there is only a jpeg and changing the URL for my blog would be very inexpensive. 😉